Skip to content

Calculators· Home

Rent vs Buy Calculator

Whether renting or buying costs less over the years you plan to stay.

Buying costs less over 10 years by · projected$18,948Full result

Your numbers

The starting numbers are examples. Replace them with yours.

Renting
Buying

Share of the home price paid up front.

The yearly rate on the loan, not the APR with fees.

Percent of the home's price. Your county or city lists the local rate.

Use 0 if there's no homeowners association.

Charged only with less than 20% down. Your lender quotes the rate.

Repairs and maintenance, as a share of the home's value.

As a share of the price.

Agent fees and transfer taxes, as a share of the sale price.

Over time

Your assumption. Home values don't rise the same amount every year.

What the down payment and closing costs could earn if you rented instead.

Result

Buying costs less over 10 years by: $18,948

Buying costs less over 10 years by

Projected

$18,948

Net cost of buying $250,996, renting $269,944, if you sold at the end of year 10.

Break-even
Year 9
From this year on, buying's net cost stays lower through year 10.
Rent, first monthEstimated
$2,200
Owning, first monthEstimated
$3,242.11
Payment, PMI, tax, insurance, HOA and upkeep.
Cash to buyEstimated
$52,000
Down payment plus closing costs.

Net cost so far

RentingBuying
Net cost so far
PeriodRentingBuying
Year 1$23,800$59,602
Year 2$48,262$82,835
Year 3$73,403$105,680
Year 4$99,241$128,113
Year 5$125,795$150,112
Year 6$153,081$171,651
Year 7$181,120$192,703
Year 8$209,930$213,240
Year 9$239,531$233,231
Year 10$269,944$250,996

Renting for 10 years

Rent paid
$302,646.41
Minus what the cash to buy could earn$52,000 invested at 5% a year
$32,702.52
Net cost of renting
$269,943.89

Buying for 10 years

Cash to buy
$52,000.00
Paid to ownPayments, PMI, tax, insurance, HOA and upkeep
$399,115.06
Minus what selling would leave$537,567 value − $32,254 selling costs − $305,193 loan balance
$200,119.42
Net cost of buying
$250,995.64

Year by year

  • Year 1

    Renting, net cost
    $23,800
    Buying, net cost
    $59,602
    Left after selling
    $31,304
    Buying ahead by
    -$35,802
  • Year 2

    Renting, net cost
    $48,262
    Buying, net cost
    $82,835
    Left after selling
    $47,216
    Buying ahead by
    -$34,573
  • Year 3

    Renting, net cost
    $73,403
    Buying, net cost
    $105,680
    Left after selling
    $63,764
    Buying ahead by
    -$32,277
  • Year 4

    Renting, net cost
    $99,241
    Buying, net cost
    $128,113
    Left after selling
    $80,977
    Buying ahead by
    -$28,872
  • Year 5

    Renting, net cost
    $125,795
    Buying, net cost
    $150,112
    Left after selling
    $98,888
    Buying ahead by
    -$24,318
  • Year 6

    Renting, net cost
    $153,081
    Buying, net cost
    $171,651
    Left after selling
    $117,529
    Buying ahead by
    -$18,570
  • Year 7

    Renting, net cost
    $181,120
    Buying, net cost
    $192,703
    Left after selling
    $136,935
    Buying ahead by
    -$11,583
  • Year 8

    Renting, net cost
    $209,930
    Buying, net cost
    $213,240
    Left after selling
    $157,142
    Buying ahead by
    -$3,310
  • Year 9

    Renting, net cost
    $239,531
    Buying, net cost
    $233,231
    Left after selling
    $178,190
    Buying ahead by
    $6,300
  • Year 10

    Renting, net cost
    $269,944
    Buying, net cost
    $250,996
    Left after selling
    $200,119
    Buying ahead by
    $18,948

Good to know

  • After 10 years, the home would be worth about $537,567 and the loan balance would be $305,193.

How it works

Each year compares the net cost of both paths. Renting costs the rent paid, minus what the down payment and closing costs could have earned invested. Buying costs everything paid to own, minus what you'd keep if you sold at the end of that year: the home's value, less selling costs and the loan balance.

How our calculators work

Assumptions

  • Rent rises 3% a year. The home's value changes 3% a year. These are assumptions, not predictions.
  • Property tax and upkeep follow the home's value; insurance and HOA dues stay the same.
  • If you rent, the down payment and closing costs are invested instead, earning 5% a year, compounded yearly. Month-to-month differences in cost aren't invested.
  • Each year's figures assume you sell at the end of that year and pay the selling costs.
  • Income tax effects (such as the mortgage interest deduction or tax on a gain) aren't included.
  • Utilities and renter's insurance are left out.
  • PMI applies only with less than 20% down and is figured on the original loan amount. It stops once the balance reaches 78% of the home's price, or halfway through the term if that comes first, as the Homeowners Protection Act sets for conventional loans. You can ask your lender to cancel it at 80%.
  • The interest rate stays the same for the whole loan (a fixed-rate mortgage).

Sources